Why clarifications exist
A backtestable strategy requires specifics. If a trading idea is missing something important, ATI will ask clarifying questions to ensure:- the strategy is deterministic
- it matches your intent
- it can be backtested correctly
Clarifications are a safety feature, not friction.
Common reasons ATI asks questions
Missing required structure
Examples:- market or timeframe missing
- direction not specified (long/short)
- no exit rules provided
Ambiguous language
Examples:- “enter on strong momentum” (what defines strong?)
- “use a tight stop” (how tight?)
- “trade when trend is bullish” (which trend definition?)
Conflicting instructions
Examples:- “trade only weekdays” + “enter during weekend pump”
- “one position at a time” + “scale in multiple entries”
How to answer clarifications
Best answers are:- short
- explicit
- numeric where possible
- consistent with the original idea
Typical clarification formats
ATI may ask:- to choose between options (A or B)
- to provide missing values (TP %, SL %, times)
- to confirm an assumption (e.g., candle-close evaluation)
1
Answer only what’s asked
Don’t rewrite the whole strategy unless you want to.
2
Use explicit numbers
Replace “tight” with “0.8%”, “short” with “15m”, etc.
3
Keep intent consistent
Your clarification should reinforce the original logic.
If you don’t know the answer
If you’re unsure, you can say:- “use standard defaults”
- “pick a conservative value”
- “optimize later”
- apply safe defaults, or
- suggest a next step
When not to optimize
Don’t over-tune early.
Clarifications help ATI match your intent with deterministic rules.